Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dio
| Ano de defesa: | 2019 |
|---|---|
| Autor(a) principal: | |
| Orientador(a): | |
| Banca de defesa: | |
| Tipo de documento: | Dissertação |
| Tipo de acesso: | Acesso aberto |
| Idioma: | por |
| Instituição de defesa: |
Universidade Federal da Fronteira Sul
Brasil Campus Chapec? Programa de P?s-Gradua??o em Estudos Lingu?sticos UFFS |
| Programa de Pós-Graduação: |
Não Informado pela instituição
|
| Departamento: |
Não Informado pela instituição
|
| País: |
Não Informado pela instituição
|
| Palavras-chave em Português: | |
| Link de acesso: | https://rd.uffs.edu.br/handle/prefix/3317 |
Resumo: | The texts that circulate today are made in many genres and increasingly employ nonverbal elements (images, colors, shapes, sounds, gestures, etc.) that integrate and combine with verbal elements (words), which characterize them as multimodal genres. These genres combine at least two semioses (modes of meaning) and therefore require readers to understand that nonverbal elements do not fulfill a mere illustrative function, that they have a sense / informative load, which have communicative purpose and, being a constituent part of these texts, they are essential in the process of constructing their meanings, influencing their comprehension and the realization of their communicative purpose. Considering the new learning demands of students regarding the reading of multimodal / multisemiotic texts, we are concerned with how these texts are worked in the reading activities proposed for them. Thus, due to the remarkable presence of the textbook in Brazilian schools, we took as source for collecting the data analyzed by this research three textbooks of the first year of high school, each book in a collection approved by the National Textbook Program - PNLD. Considering also the characteristics and the pedagogical potentialities of the strips as a multimodal discursive / textual genre, our objective is to verify which reading skills are developed by the activities proposed for this genre by the three selected books. In addition, we are interested in investigating whether these reading activities proposed for the strips include the processing of the nonverbal language that constitutes this genre and its integration with the verbal language that makes up these texts. Data analysis revealed that the semantic relationship established between the verbal and nonverbal languages that constitute the strips proposed by the three selected textbooks is complementary, pointing out that most of these texts have great potential for reading activities to address skills that include the textual processing of visual language and its integration with verbal language. As for the analysis of the reading activities proposed for the 21 selected strips, we emphasize that none of the three books promotes the development of critical analysis skills of the strips either in terms of textual structure, content or discourse. The data also reveal that, in the three textbooks, some reading skills are not addressed by the reading comprehension activities proposed for the selected strips, although some of these texts present material that favors the approach of these neglected skills. Although the three books propose activities that address reading skills that include visual language processing and its integration with verbal language, in general, their didactic treatment in reading activities does not favor the mobilization of reading skills to the specifics of this multimodal genre. Thus, these didactic materials limit reading teaching and learning and contribute to the multimodal literacy of high school students from Brazilian public schools. We hope that this work can contribute to reflections on the need for a reading education that promotes multiliteracy and a teaching-learning that favors the development of specific skills for reading the strips, but also of other multimodal genres. |
| id |
UFFS_e2bb8d6be70ab09ba1daf4249f9031d0 |
|---|---|
| oai_identifier_str |
oai:rd.uffs.edu.br:prefix/3317 |
| network_acronym_str |
UFFS |
| network_name_str |
Repositório Institucional da UFFS (Repositório Digital da UFFS) |
| repository_id_str |
|
| spelling |
Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dioG?neros textuaisCompreens?o da leituraLivro did?ticoThe texts that circulate today are made in many genres and increasingly employ nonverbal elements (images, colors, shapes, sounds, gestures, etc.) that integrate and combine with verbal elements (words), which characterize them as multimodal genres. These genres combine at least two semioses (modes of meaning) and therefore require readers to understand that nonverbal elements do not fulfill a mere illustrative function, that they have a sense / informative load, which have communicative purpose and, being a constituent part of these texts, they are essential in the process of constructing their meanings, influencing their comprehension and the realization of their communicative purpose. Considering the new learning demands of students regarding the reading of multimodal / multisemiotic texts, we are concerned with how these texts are worked in the reading activities proposed for them. Thus, due to the remarkable presence of the textbook in Brazilian schools, we took as source for collecting the data analyzed by this research three textbooks of the first year of high school, each book in a collection approved by the National Textbook Program - PNLD. Considering also the characteristics and the pedagogical potentialities of the strips as a multimodal discursive / textual genre, our objective is to verify which reading skills are developed by the activities proposed for this genre by the three selected books. In addition, we are interested in investigating whether these reading activities proposed for the strips include the processing of the nonverbal language that constitutes this genre and its integration with the verbal language that makes up these texts. Data analysis revealed that the semantic relationship established between the verbal and nonverbal languages that constitute the strips proposed by the three selected textbooks is complementary, pointing out that most of these texts have great potential for reading activities to address skills that include the textual processing of visual language and its integration with verbal language. As for the analysis of the reading activities proposed for the 21 selected strips, we emphasize that none of the three books promotes the development of critical analysis skills of the strips either in terms of textual structure, content or discourse. The data also reveal that, in the three textbooks, some reading skills are not addressed by the reading comprehension activities proposed for the selected strips, although some of these texts present material that favors the approach of these neglected skills. Although the three books propose activities that address reading skills that include visual language processing and its integration with verbal language, in general, their didactic treatment in reading activities does not favor the mobilization of reading skills to the specifics of this multimodal genre. Thus, these didactic materials limit reading teaching and learning and contribute to the multimodal literacy of high school students from Brazilian public schools. We hope that this work can contribute to reflections on the need for a reading education that promotes multiliteracy and a teaching-learning that favors the development of specific skills for reading the strips, but also of other multimodal genres.Os textos que circulam na atualidade se realizam em in?meros g?neros e empregam cada vez mais elementos n?o verbais (imagens, cores, formas, sons, gestos etc.) que se integram e se combinam com elementos verbais (palavras), o que os caracteriza como g?neros multimodais. Esses g?neros combinam pelo menos duas semioses (modos de significa??o) e por isso demandam dos leitores a compreens?o de que os elementos n?o verbais n?o cumprem uma mera fun??o ilustrativa, que eles possuem uma carga de sentido/informatividade, que apresentam prop?sito(s) comunicativo(s) e que, sendo parte constituinte desses textos, s?o essenciais no processo de constru??o de sentidos dos mesmos, influenciando na sua compreens?o e na efetiva??o de seu prop?sito comunicativo. Considerando as novas demandas de aprendizagem dos alunos quanto ? leitura de textos multimodais/multissemi?ticos, preocupa-nos como esses textos s?o trabalhados nas atividades de leitura propostas para eles. Assim, devido ? marcante presen?a do livro did?tico nas escolas brasileiras, tomamos como fonte para coleta dos dados analisados por esta pesquisa tr?s livros did?ticos de 1? ano do ensino m?dio, sendo cada livro de uma cole??o aprovada pelo Programa Nacional do Livro Did?tico ? PNLD. Considerando ainda as caracter?sticas e as potencialidades pedag?gicas das tiras enquanto g?nero discursivo/textual multimodal, nosso objetivo ? verificar quais habilidades de leitura s?o desenvolvidas pelas atividades propostas para este g?nero pelos tr?s livros de L?ngua Portuguesa selecionados. Al?m disso, interessanos investigar se essas atividades de leitura propostas para as tiras incluem o processamento da linguagem n?o verbal que constitui esse g?nero e a integra??o desta com a linguagem verbal que comp?e esses textos. A an?lise dos dados revelou que a rela??o sem?ntica que se estabelece entre as linguagens verbal e n?o verbal que constituem as tiras propostas pelos tr?s livros did?ticos selecionados ? de complementaridade, apontando que a maioria desses textos apresenta grande potencialidade para que as atividades de leitura abordem habilidades que incluam o processamento textual da linguagem visual e de sua integra??o com a linguagem verbal. Quanto ?s analises das atividades de leitura propostas para as 21 tiras selecionadas, destacamos que nenhum dos tr?s livros promove o desenvolvimento das habilidades de an?lise cr?tica das tiras seja quanto ? estrutura textual, seja quanto ao conte?do que esses textos abordam ou ao discurso que veiculam. Os dados revelam tamb?m que, nos tr?s livros did?ticos, algumas habilidades de leitura n?o s?o abordadas pelas atividades de compreens?o leitora propostas para as tiras selecionadas, apesar de alguns desses textos apresentarem material que favorece a abordagem dessas habilidades negligenciadas. Pontuamos ainda que, embora os tr?s livros proponham atividades que abordam habilidades de leitura que abrangem o processamento da linguagem visual e de sua integra??o com a linguagem verbal, de modo geral, seu tratamento did?tico em atividades de leitura pouco favorece a mobiliza??o de capacidades leitoras para as especificidades desse g?nero multimodal. Assim, esses materiais did?ticos limitam o ensino-aprendizagem de leitura e contribuem medianamente para o letramento multimodal de alunos do Ensino M?dio das escolas p?blicas brasileiras. Esperamos que este trabalho possa contribuir para reflex?es acerca da necessidade de uma forma??o leitora que fomente o multiletramento e de um ensino-aprendizagem que favore?a o desenvolvimento de habilidades espec?ficas para a leitura das tiras, mas tamb?m de outros g?neros multimodais.Universidade Federal da Fronteira SulBrasilCampus Chapec?Programa de P?s-Gradua??o em Estudos Lingu?sticosUFFSFinger-Kratochvil, ClaudiaSilva, Izabelle Fernandes da20192019-12-16T12:18:11Z20192019-12-16T12:18:11Z2019info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersioninfo:eu-repo/semantics/masterThesishttps://rd.uffs.edu.br/handle/prefix/3317porinfo:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessreponame:Repositório Institucional da UFFS (Repositório Digital da UFFS)instname:Universidade Federal Fronteira do Sul (UFFS)instacron:UFFS2021-09-29T16:37:05Zoai:rd.uffs.edu.br:prefix/3317Repositório InstitucionalPUBhttps://rd.uffs.edu.br/oai/requestfranciele.cruz@uffs.edu.bropendoar:39242021-09-29T16:37:05Repositório Institucional da UFFS (Repositório Digital da UFFS) - Universidade Federal Fronteira do Sul (UFFS)false |
| dc.title.none.fl_str_mv |
Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dio |
| title |
Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dio |
| spellingShingle |
Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dio Silva, Izabelle Fernandes da G?neros textuais Compreens?o da leitura Livro did?tico |
| title_short |
Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dio |
| title_full |
Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dio |
| title_fullStr |
Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dio |
| title_full_unstemmed |
Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dio |
| title_sort |
Compreens?o leitora do g?nero multimodal tira: uma an?lise de atividades de leitura propostas por livros did?ticos de l?ngua portuguesa do ensino m?dio |
| author |
Silva, Izabelle Fernandes da |
| author_facet |
Silva, Izabelle Fernandes da |
| author_role |
author |
| dc.contributor.none.fl_str_mv |
Finger-Kratochvil, Claudia |
| dc.contributor.author.fl_str_mv |
Silva, Izabelle Fernandes da |
| dc.subject.por.fl_str_mv |
G?neros textuais Compreens?o da leitura Livro did?tico |
| topic |
G?neros textuais Compreens?o da leitura Livro did?tico |
| description |
The texts that circulate today are made in many genres and increasingly employ nonverbal elements (images, colors, shapes, sounds, gestures, etc.) that integrate and combine with verbal elements (words), which characterize them as multimodal genres. These genres combine at least two semioses (modes of meaning) and therefore require readers to understand that nonverbal elements do not fulfill a mere illustrative function, that they have a sense / informative load, which have communicative purpose and, being a constituent part of these texts, they are essential in the process of constructing their meanings, influencing their comprehension and the realization of their communicative purpose. Considering the new learning demands of students regarding the reading of multimodal / multisemiotic texts, we are concerned with how these texts are worked in the reading activities proposed for them. Thus, due to the remarkable presence of the textbook in Brazilian schools, we took as source for collecting the data analyzed by this research three textbooks of the first year of high school, each book in a collection approved by the National Textbook Program - PNLD. Considering also the characteristics and the pedagogical potentialities of the strips as a multimodal discursive / textual genre, our objective is to verify which reading skills are developed by the activities proposed for this genre by the three selected books. In addition, we are interested in investigating whether these reading activities proposed for the strips include the processing of the nonverbal language that constitutes this genre and its integration with the verbal language that makes up these texts. Data analysis revealed that the semantic relationship established between the verbal and nonverbal languages that constitute the strips proposed by the three selected textbooks is complementary, pointing out that most of these texts have great potential for reading activities to address skills that include the textual processing of visual language and its integration with verbal language. As for the analysis of the reading activities proposed for the 21 selected strips, we emphasize that none of the three books promotes the development of critical analysis skills of the strips either in terms of textual structure, content or discourse. The data also reveal that, in the three textbooks, some reading skills are not addressed by the reading comprehension activities proposed for the selected strips, although some of these texts present material that favors the approach of these neglected skills. Although the three books propose activities that address reading skills that include visual language processing and its integration with verbal language, in general, their didactic treatment in reading activities does not favor the mobilization of reading skills to the specifics of this multimodal genre. Thus, these didactic materials limit reading teaching and learning and contribute to the multimodal literacy of high school students from Brazilian public schools. We hope that this work can contribute to reflections on the need for a reading education that promotes multiliteracy and a teaching-learning that favors the development of specific skills for reading the strips, but also of other multimodal genres. |
| publishDate |
2019 |
| dc.date.none.fl_str_mv |
2019 2019-12-16T12:18:11Z 2019 2019-12-16T12:18:11Z 2019 |
| dc.type.status.fl_str_mv |
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion |
| dc.type.driver.fl_str_mv |
info:eu-repo/semantics/masterThesis |
| format |
masterThesis |
| status_str |
publishedVersion |
| dc.identifier.uri.fl_str_mv |
https://rd.uffs.edu.br/handle/prefix/3317 |
| url |
https://rd.uffs.edu.br/handle/prefix/3317 |
| dc.language.iso.fl_str_mv |
por |
| language |
por |
| dc.rights.driver.fl_str_mv |
info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess |
| eu_rights_str_mv |
openAccess |
| dc.publisher.none.fl_str_mv |
Universidade Federal da Fronteira Sul Brasil Campus Chapec? Programa de P?s-Gradua??o em Estudos Lingu?sticos UFFS |
| publisher.none.fl_str_mv |
Universidade Federal da Fronteira Sul Brasil Campus Chapec? Programa de P?s-Gradua??o em Estudos Lingu?sticos UFFS |
| dc.source.none.fl_str_mv |
reponame:Repositório Institucional da UFFS (Repositório Digital da UFFS) instname:Universidade Federal Fronteira do Sul (UFFS) instacron:UFFS |
| instname_str |
Universidade Federal Fronteira do Sul (UFFS) |
| instacron_str |
UFFS |
| institution |
UFFS |
| reponame_str |
Repositório Institucional da UFFS (Repositório Digital da UFFS) |
| collection |
Repositório Institucional da UFFS (Repositório Digital da UFFS) |
| repository.name.fl_str_mv |
Repositório Institucional da UFFS (Repositório Digital da UFFS) - Universidade Federal Fronteira do Sul (UFFS) |
| repository.mail.fl_str_mv |
franciele.cruz@uffs.edu.br |
| _version_ |
1868248301427490816 |